The Story: Michael Holt, aka Mister Terrific, is known as the world’s third smartest man, using his brains as well as his inventions to thwart science gone wrong. With a new will to live after coming to terms with the death of his wife, a successful high-tech corporation, and havign recently founded an institute for the next great minds of the future, you’d think Michael would have it made. But you always have a target on your back when you’re that successful, and someone’s about to take a shot.
The Verdict: I was pretty bummed when I saw the JSA wouldn’t play anywhere into the “New 52”. I actually like them better than the Justice League, and I’ll definitely miss characters like Dr. Mid-Nite, Hourman and Stargirl. And while I think all of them would have made for cooler solo series, Mister Terrific isn’t so bad of a choice, but this inaugural outing doesn’t do him much justice. It’s obvious from this first issue DC is poising the character to be their answer to Iron Man, which is a bit of a disappointment. While all of those personality traits were always present, his more radical views, such as being an atheist, refusing to accept anything supernatural, and always being able to see what’s in front of him have generally taken precedence. This time around however the playboy role has been played up in favor of the rest, and that may not exactly help this character stand out the way DC is hoping. Also worth mentioning are some racial undertones that are played with; they come off very forced. Terrific isn’t Luke Cage or Black Lightning. He doesn’t come from the streets. Are we really expected to take any type of racial issues a multi-million dollar business man that’s living in a swank penthouse may face seriously?
One positive I did take away from this issue is that Karen Starr, better known as Power Girl, is alive and well in the new universe. She really doesn’t do much here, but she could certainly add some spice to this book if she’s going to be a mainstay. Holt’s staunch ideals on the supernatural also look like they’re going to be tested fairly early, it’s just a shame that how adamantly against the idea of those types of things existing he is isn’t explored very much, so the impact may well be lost on new readers. Gianluca Gugliotta’s artwork is a mixed bag throughout the issue. I don’t know if it’s the inker, the colors, or what, but his work varies wildly here. I thought his Marvel work was fairly solid and unique; here it’s occasionally downright ugly. If the guy is turning in rushed work due to time constraints, maybe it’d be wise to move on to someone else. And if it's due to a different inker or colorist, make a change as soon as possible.
The Outlook: “Meh” is probably the best word to use. Not much happens in this issue to distinguish Terrific as anything other than a poor man’s Tony Stark, and the sad thing is those of us that have read JSA over the years knows he’s much more than that. Throw that in with the lame twist at the end, and I can’t say I have too much faith in the book for the long-term.
Continue to week three reviews!